“A white-pot custard for my white-pot queen,” cried Kemp, waving his bauble. “Mark this boy,…A white-pot mermaid custard, with a crust, lashings of cream, eggs, apple-pulse and spice, a little sugar, and manchet bread. Away! Be Swift!” (Tales of the Mermaid Tavern, by Alfred Noyes)
The topic and contents of this post are taken from a video we produced a couple of months ago. Based on the amount of feedback we received, this recipe is apparently a viewer favorite. It’s definitely a favorite of ours!
The name “White Pot” originates from the Devon region of England. But this sweet, buttery custard bread pudding, layered with sweetmeats (dried fruits) and topped with a caramelized sugar crust, was known to colonial cooks as well, if not by name, by construction. As far as we are concerned, this dessert deserves a culinary resurgence.
You will need a sloped-sided baking pan for this recipe that holds about a quart, such as a Charlotte mould (said to be named after King George III’s wife), a trade kettle, or any other sloped-sided ceramic or metal vessel. We used a Tin Bowl in our video. A medium rectangular bread pan will work as well.
If you use your range oven at home, preheat your oven to 350-degrees (F). A wood-fired oven should be heated to full temperature and then swept out and allowed to cool to medium heat. If you use a Dutch oven, prepare a small fire from which you can use embers. Or if using charcoal briquettes with your Dutch oven, use this formula: for the ring of coals used beneath your Dutch oven, take the diameter of your Dutch oven in inches minus two (example: if your Dutch oven is 12” in diameter, use 10 briquettes beneath). For the ring of coals for the top of your Dutch oven, take the diameter in inches plus two (example: for a 12” Dutch oven use 14 coals on top). That will heat your dutch oven to approximately 350 degrees.
If you are using a wood-fired oven or Dutch oven, be sure to also use a trivet onto which you can place your baking pan. This will prevent the bottom of your White Pot from burning. If you don’t have a baking trivet, a tripod of pebbles will do in the meantime.
1 pint heavy cream
1 cinnamon stick (or 1⁄4 t ground cinnamon)
1⁄4 t ground mace
1⁄4 t freshly grated or ground nutmeg
dash of salt
2 large eggs
1 large egg yolk
3 T sugar
1 loaf of white bread (we used soft Italian
bread, but white sandwich bread will work)
1⁄2 cup (1 stick) softened butter, plus enough
to butter the inside of your baking dish
1 cup raisins
1 cup dates, pitted, and sliced
additional sugar for sprinkling on top
Liberally butter the inside of your cooking vessel and set aside. Do not skip this step or you’ll be disappointed. Mix the heavy cream, spices, and salt. Set over medium/ low heat and bring to a simmer, occasionally stirring to prevent a skin from forming. Remove from heat to cool slightly.
Beat together the eggs, egg yolk, and sugar. When the cream mixture has cooled slightly, remove the cinnamon stick, and pour 2 to 3 tablespoons of the cream into your egg mixture, whisking as you pour until the cream is well incorporated. This will temper your eggs so they will not curdle. Continue to add approximately 1⁄4 cup of cream at a time to your egg mixture, whisking well as you pour, until all the cream is incorporated into the eggs. This is our custard liquid. Set it aside.
Slice your bread into approximately 1⁄2” slices, then trim away the crusts leaving only the slices of crumb. Butter your bread slices fairly liberally. This works best if your butter is softened.
Place a layer of bread, buttered-side down, into the bottom of your buttered baking pan. Push your bread down just a bit, but take care not to compress it. Fill in any gaps with smaller pieces of bread. Sprinkle a layer of raisins and dates on top of your first bread layer. It does not have to be a solid layer of fruit, as the raisins will expand while baking. Repeat the bread layer once more, placing the buttered-side down. Top with another raisin/date layer.
Once you have two layers of bread and two layers of fruit, pour enough custard liquid to fill the pan just to the top of the bread. Repeat layering as described in the previous paragraph. Cover with just enough custard to cover the bread layer. Continue until your pan is full.
Top off your pan with a layer of bread, buttered-side up. The custard liquid will soak up into this layer. Sprinkle about a tablespoon of sugar on top. Your White Pot is assembled and ready to bake.
Baking times will vary, depending on the size of your pan and the actual temperature of your oven. Check your White Pot after 30 minutes. The top will be well browned when it’s done. Your White Pot may jiggle a bit when jostled, but there should not be liquid pooled in the middle. If the top is not browned, continue to bake it, checking every 10 minutes or so to make sure it doesn’t burn.
Once your White Pot is finished baking, remove it from the oven and allow it to cool for 10 minutes. Carefully run a knife around the inside edge of the baking dish. If you are using a tin-lined pan, be especially careful with your knife so you don’t damage your tin lining. Invert the pan onto a plate and rap on the pan and jiggle it to get the White Pot to separate from the bottom of the pan. This is why it is important to butter your pan liberally.
An extra special finishing touch for your White Pot is to sprinkle it with sugar and brown the sugar as you would on a creme brulee. To do this in a period manner, you can use a Salamander or an ash shovel. Heat the plate of the salamander until it is cherry red, and prop the plate over the sugared top until it bubbles and browns. (Be very careful doing this. Handling a hot salamander requires a good pair of thermal gloves). You may also brown the sugared top using a modern kitchen torch or a conventional oven broiler. If you use a broiler, watch your White Pot closely to avoid over browning.
Slice into wedges. White Pot may be eaten warm or cold. It is delicious topped with a little cream or sack (sweet sherry).
Made this tonight — wow! My wife abhors raisins, so I used dried cranberries and dried apples, it came out great. My son told me “I think you can do better, Dad… you’d better try again!”
Pingback: Please Bring Back the Puddings! | Savoring the Past
I made this tonight! My husband wants to marry me all over again! I don’t care for raisins but I used them and dried cranberries, added a little rum extract and a bit of peach brandy…then served it with a hot buttered rum sauce and a pour of heavy cream….told my husband maybe next time I’d use apples then read the post above! Now I can’t wait to try to apples! Wonderful end to a great week! Can’t wait to try making this in our dutch oven while attending Rendezvous!
Excellent blog you have here.. It’s hard to find high quality writing like yours
nowadays. I truly appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!
First off I would like to say that your videos are a lot of fun, please keep them coming. I really enjoy them and my son loves all the recipes I have tried so far. I have a couple of questions: 1. What size Dutch oven are you using for the white pot recipe? 2. Can you recommend a brand and/or give a little more detail on the type of sherry you use? Thanks again.
Thank you, Karl.
As for the Dutch Ovens, we have used different sizes with equal success. We offer three sizes on our website: http://jas-townsend.com/advanced_search_result.php?keywords=dutch+oven&search_in_description=1&osCsid=ef84427203a1f3088b16fb08b97b21c7&x=-389&y=-140. The 12″ tends to be a bit more versatile as it will hold larger dishes such as pies. If you are going to bake in a Dutch oven, I encourage you to use a trivet as well.
As for Sherry, I really don’t have a recommendation, other than I suggest you use a higher quality sherry as opposed to a cooking sherry that you may find at your grocery store.
I found “Dry Sack”. It is excellent: https://www.arlingtonwine.net/sherry/Bodegas-Williams-and-Humbert-Dry-Sack-Sherry-w3914455ao
Cooking wines that you get in a grocery store tend to be salt added – to disincline people from drinking them … stupid temperance movement! you should just go to a reputable boozeria and get something you would actually enjoy drinking – never cheap out on ingredients, if you wouldn’t drink it, you shouldn’t cook with it! One thing I have learned from some 20+ years of Roman, medieval, Persian and Renaissance cooking as a hobby is that a little research into the ingredients used, and a go at trying to find the modern equivalent can go a long way to turning a mediocre dish into an excellent one. [There tends to be reasons for why our ancestors used what they did!]
Pingback: Currant Challenges | Savoring the Past
Followed your recipie except I used straw berries! It’s
well I hit enter on accident, but it’s in the oven as I type this.
Pingback: Eliza Leslie’s Bread and Butter Pudding | Revolutionary Pie
where can I buy an old fashion pudding pot pan?